Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Niamh Algar as Dr Lucinda Edwards in Malpractice
© ITV

Malpractice viewers very divided over new ITV drama - here's why

Niamh Algar stars in the series

Nicky Morris
TV and film writer
April 24, 2023
Share this:

ITV's new medical drama, Malpractice, premiered on Sunday night and viewers are divided over the series. 

The five-parter, which is written by former NHS doctor Grace Ofori-Attah, follows Dr Lucinda Edwards (Niamh Algar), a dedicated doctor whose life is derailed when her shift ends in the death of an opioid overdose victim. Despite the support of her medical supervisor, Edith's grieving father demands an inquiry into Lucinda's actions on the night the patient died. 

WATCH: Niamh Algar stars in ITV's new drama Malpractice

Taking to Twitter, some viewers couldn't help but notice inaccuracies in the new drama. One person wrote: "#Malpractice lives up to its name with all the medical inaccuracies they've managed to squeeze into the first part," while another added: "I do like this new #Malpractice show on ITV but the amount of inaccuracies is driving me mental."

A third person tweeted: "The only thing that is surprisingly accurately portrayed in this less than factual and exaggerated series, is how underfunded and overworked the health service is. In the real world, Lucinda wouldn't even have had time for a smoke break let alone go to the loo."

MORE: 25 most shocking and heartbreaking TV show deaths that we'll never get over

MORE: Grantchester star Tom Brittney shares disappointing update on season eight

Many viewers, however, were glued to the screen and also took to social media to praise the gripping first episode. One person wrote: "Watched the first episode of #Malpractice… wow. [My] heart was in my mouth through most of it!!! @PhilipBarantini has done it again. Absolutely brilliant, going to have to binge the whole lot now!!"

Niamh Algar as Dr Lucinda Edwards in Malpractice© ITV
Niamh Algar stars as Dr Lucinda Edwards in Malpractice

A second fan tweeted: "First episode of #Malpractice done! Brilliantly directed by @PhilipBarantini, really captured the stress and anxiety of working as a nurse. I can't imagine what it must be like! @dedwardscasting doing a top job with casting too! Can't wait to see who else enters play," while a third added: "#Malpractice you got me hooked. It's like Line of Duty meets casualty."

Other viewers couldn't help but binge-watch all five episodes, and one person applauded the entire series as a whole, writing: "Just finished #Malpractice on ITV and it was honestly such a good show. There were parts that were so tense but also emotional at the same time."

Don't want to miss a story? Sign up to our What to Watch newsletter and get the heads-up on the shows and films everyone’s talking about.

Sign up to Off Camera for all the gossip and goings-on from the wonderful world of TV and film

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film

See more