Skip to main contentSkip to footer
James Anthony-Rose as Richard Carmody, Callum Woodhouse as Tristan Farnon & Anna Madeley as Mrs Hall, Rachel Shenton as Helen Alderson, Nicholas Ralph as James Herriot & Samuel West Siegfried Farnon© PBS / Channel 5 Television / Jay Brooks

All Creatures Great and Small viewers issue same plea after disappointment in series five finale

The hit Channel 5 period drama will return with a Christmas special

Nicky Morris
TV and film writer
2 hours ago
Share this:

Series five of All Creatures Great and Small drew to an end on Thursday night and while it's safe to say viewers thoroughly enjoyed the episode, some were a little disappointed at the lack of scenes between Siegfried (Samuel West) and Mrs Hall (Anna Madeley). 

Fans have long been hoping that the vet and his housekeeper would finally confess their love for one another in season five after flirtation between the pair ramped up in the earlier episodes. 

WATCH: Have you enjoyed series five?

Taking to social media, one fan pleaded with the show's writers to give the duo more screen time in the upcoming sixth season, writing: "Brilliant acting as always #AllCreaturesGreatAndSmall  #acgas but really missing the screen time between Siegfried and Audrey. Please can the Christmas Special and Series 6 be promising," while another added: "So far the slow burn has been done so well, gradually, realistically, mindfully. But now it feels as if they've extinguished that with a bang. Please tell me that this is not the death of a very good ship that is really loved in the #ACGAS fandom?"

Samuel West and Anna Madeley in All Creatures Great and Small © Channel 5
Fans were hoping for more scenes between Siegfried and Mrs Hall

A third viewer was more optimistic and wrote: "Deciding that they've started giving us less Audrey and Siegfried for a reason. Like we'll all start going through withdrawals, and then they can give us some amazing moments in the Christmas special so they'll be more impactful?" Another said the lack of scenes between the fan-favourite pairing was "disappointing." 

Anna Madeley as Mrs Hall in All Creatures© Channel 5
Viewers are loving the 'slow-burn romance'

Addressing the slow-burn romance between Mrs Hall and Siegfried, actors Anna and Samuel kept their cards close to their chest during their recent appearance on ITV's Lorraine. 

While Samuel said the pair would "be a disaster" together, Anna added that there "are lots of reasons not to" take their relationship further. However, Samuel did add that the pair might get together in the distant future. "We were thinking maybe when the children have grown up and have left home, no telly. There's not much else to do," suggested the Slow Horses star. 

Anna Madeley, Samuel West
'Lorraine' TV show, London, UK - 03 Oct 2024© Ken McKay/ITV/Shutterstock
Anna and Samuel were tight-lipped over their characters' future

Despite the lack of scenes between Siegfried and Mrs Hall, fans loved the finale and were full of praise for the cast.

One person penned: "What a gorgeous wonderful episode. Made me cry and made me laugh and showed us proper family at end. Too adorable," while another added: "Fab episode this week. Excellent writing, brilliantly acted. This is a tight team."

Drew Cain, Tony Pitts, Callum Woodhouse, Samuel West, Mark Chatterton, Gabriel Quigley, Imogen Clawson, Rach Shenton, Nicholas Ralph, Anna Madeley in All Creatures Great and Small© Helen Williams / Playground Prod / Channel 5 Television
Fans praised the latest series as it drew to a close

A third fan penned: "It's ended way too soon, what a brilliant episode tonight. Really going to miss #ACGAS & its wonderful, incredible cast."

All Creatures Great and Small will return to Channel 5 in December with a Christmas Special. 

Sign up to Off Camera for all the gossip and goings-on from the wonderful world of TV and film

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film

See more