Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Sherwood is one of BBC's best dramas© BBC

BBC drama fans say is 'as good as Broadchurch' shocks viewers

BBC thriller Sherwood leaves viewers stunned

Edward Lauder
Senior online reporter
13 hours ago
Share this:

BBC viewers have praised drama series Sherwood as being "as good as Broadchurch", with many left shocked by the compelling and gritty storylines.

The show, created and written by James Graham, premiered in June 2022 and quickly became a favourite with fans and critics alike. Many have called it one of the "cleverest" and "most compelling" BBC dramas in recent years.

WATCH: The trailer for Sherwood series 2

Viewers rave about BBC's Sherwood

David Morrissey and Terence Maynard in Sherwood© BBC
David Morrissey and Terence Maynard in Sherwood

The political thriller was so popular that it was swiftly renewed for a second series, which aired in August 2024. Now a third series has already been announced, leaving fans eagerly awaiting more.

Set in the Nottinghamshire mining district of Ashfield, Sherwood draws inspiration from real-life events, specifically two shocking murders that occurred in July 2004. The drama is centred around the community’s deep-seated divisions following the 1980s miners' strike.

Real-life events that inspired Sherwood

Lesley Manville in Sherwood© Jack Merriman
Lesley Manville in Sherwood

The first series explores the fallout from the tragic murders of hairdresser Chanel Taylor and trade unionist Keith Frogson. Both events shook the local community to its core, revealing underlying tensions that had simmered for decades.

In series two, Sherwood moves forward in time, delving deeper into contemporary conflicts. Viewers witness the turmoil of gang wars, intense family dynamics, revenge, and betrayal.

Sherwood features a remarkable cast, including David Morrissey, Lesley Manville, Sharlene Whyte, and David Harewood. The powerful performances have captivated audiences, earning widespread acclaim.

One viewer described the drama as "television dynamite", while another called it a "five-star show" due to the outstanding performances and gripping narrative.

Fans compare Sherwood to Broadchurch

David Tennant and Olivia Colman in Broadchurch© BBC
David Tennant and Olivia Colman in Broadchurch

Many fans have compared the show's gripping intensity to another BBC hit, Broadchurch. One viewer wrote: "Ridiculously first rate. Reminds me of the top-notch gravitas of Broadchurch, same unimpeachably high production values and knockout writing and acting."

Another viewer said: "This series is an eye opener to the real world of political policing in the UK. A great series and a great watch. Not for people who aren't intelligent."

Fans have also highlighted the realism of the storylines. One viewer said: "Stunning. Great actors. Clever plot. Well thought out. I wasn't expecting how good it would be."

High praise from critics

David Morrissey stars in Sherwood season 2© BBC
David Morrissey stars in Sherwood season 2

The Guardian described Sherwood as "television dynamite", with others praising its careful balance of drama and historical accuracy. Critics have also highlighted James Graham's authentic portrayal, rooted in his own experience growing up near the events depicted.

One fan shared: "An incredibly rich and believable series. Unlike so many other TV mysteries, there's an actual mystery at the heart of this."

Another viewer praised the clever plot, stating: "This has proven to be one of the best in its genre. The beauty of the show is the separate stories and character build. Very well done."

Sherwood has set a high bar for BBC dramas, with audiences eagerly awaiting the arrival of series three.

Sherwood is available to stream now on BBC iPlayer.

Sign up to our TV & Film newsletter for The Emmy Edit’s highlights and the latest releases in What to Watch

By entering your details, you are agreeing to HELLO! Magazine User Data Protection Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information, please click here.

More TV and Film

See more