Older mother and daughter spending time together at home drinking coffee and discussing

Why is hating on how you look a bonding experience?

HELLO!'s Second Act columnist Rosie Green laments why we waste time criticising ourselves

By: Rosie Green

August 9, 2024Aug 9, 2024, 4:30 PM GMT+1

When Kate Winslet told Harper's Bazaar last week, "I don't know a single contemporary of mine who grew up seeing her mother looking in the mirror and saying, 'I look nice!'", there were millions of us nodding in recognition.

She said: "My mother never did, it was always, 'Oh God, I don't think I can wear this, do I look hippy, does my bum look big?'”

Those of us in Winslet’s age bracket (she’s 50 next year) can all remember our female relatives sitting around the kitchen table eating Ryvita and pimped-up cottage cheese bemoaning their 'terrible cellulite', 'fat thighs' and 'cankles.'

Kate Winslet slightly smiling in a white suit — Kate Winslet spoke sense in her latest interview

That chatter formed the soundtrack of our teenage years along with the Top of the Pops theme tune and the ice cream van's chimes.

It was eavesdropping on those conversations that led me to understand that to be a socially successful female, you should be next level self-depreciative about your appearance. Hating on how you looked was bonding, because it meant you all shared mutual insecurities. But the result was a vicious circle of negative chatter that ended up with everyone feeling rubbish.

More from Rosie

(N.B. Recent research from the Cairnmillar Institute in Australia suggests that responding to your friend's negative body chatter with your own, i.e. "If you are a pig, then I'm a hippo," will make them feel better while you feel worse.)

As I've developed more understanding of how the brain works, I've learnt that what you say about yourself, even if only for bonding purposes, affects your self-confidence over time.

READ: Why is 'she loves herself' still an insult?

Repeat anything enough and it becomes your truth. And a negative self-regard can limit personal growth, meaning you don't take chances in life or love.

I think most of us have now sussed that negative talk about yourself is not helpful. But I still have a friend who, on arrival at my house, will berate their appearance for a full five minutes before we get onto making a cup of tea.

Rosie Green journalist posing on porch wearing green floral skirt — Rosie Green realised that negative self-talk helps nobody

I've always tried not to put myself down in front of my children. And more recently I am making a conscious effort to respond to an appearance-based compliment with, "Thank you," rather than, "Oh my God, you must be kidding, I look like a warthog."

The next generation

My teenage daughter tells me her generation tries to compliment each other on attributes other than looks. So rather than say to a friend, "Your hair looks lovely," they'll say, "Your energy is great." I can see that that's the way forward. But, honestly, it’s hard. Like my aforementioned friend, the habit is ingrained.

Rosie Green with her daughter Sophia — Rosie Green's daughter focuses on non-appearance compliments

My daughter also says it is categorically wrong to comment negatively on other people's appearance. Even if you don't know that person. And they can't hear. Her eyes widen with horror when I tell her about the late 90s gossip magazines and their front page pictures of celebrities with their cellulite/thinning hair/waistline bulges circled and highlighted.

ROSIE'S COLUMN: My advice to Victoria Beckham as Harper turns 13: brace yourself!

A few decades on I recognise how destructive this was. So, we are making progress.

I'll leave the final words to Kate, who sagely said: "We waste so much time being down on ourselves and I'm just not doing it ever again."

Love midlife? Join Second Act today!

blonde woman in a pink jumper holding her head — Say HELLO! to your Second Act

HELLO! originally launched its Second Act hub to reframe midlife and beyond as a celebratory, exciting new chapter full of endless possibilities. From inspirational tales of women who refuse to fade into the background, to valuable advice on navigating relationships, finances and health issues – we've featured them all. And such has been the overwhelmingly positive response from readers, we are now turning the hub into a FULL and FREE community where women like you can come together to shape something truly inspiring.

The cornerstones of the community will be two brand new newsletters. One monthly and one weekly. We are really excited about the monthly newsletter which will be themed and written by one of our roster of leading Second Act voices, including our editor at large, Rosie Green. The content will be reserved exclusively for Second Act subscribers.

We are also launching a monthly mentoring series, in the form of a five-minute video sent directly to your inbox featuring financial professionals, hormone specialists, life coaches and more. Again, it will be reserved exclusively for subscribers.

Below we have listed the inaugural benefits, and more will be added as we grow and shape the community. If you wish to help us shape our community, please take part in our one-slide survey here.